Especially if the softness is accompanied by a bad smell or visible decay.
Mold
Visible mold is a clear sign that the potato is deteriorating.
Don’t simply cut away a large area of mold and assume the entire potato is fine.
When in doubt, discard it.
A Strong Rotten Smell
Fresh potatoes have a mild earthy smell.
A strong, unpleasant, rotten odor is a completely different story.
If you open the bag and immediately think, “Something is definitely wrong here,” listen to that warning sign.
Extensive
There’s more to discover. Continue to the next page for the rest of this article.